Friday, October 07, 2005

Beldar answers Krauthammer and asks a question

I am really dismayed at the good doctor. As Beldar explains, it is likely to do to a failure of imagination. Methinks the failure quite massive.

He also passes on some info from the Dallas Morning News:
Ms. Miers lived with her mother, Sally, and younger brother Jeb during her SMU undergraduate and law school years. Her father, Morris Miers, suffered a stroke during her freshman year, leaving the family in financial straits.

Concerned that she couldn't afford to keep her daughter in school, Ms. Miers' mother telephoned SMU President Willis M. Tate, seeking help, said the nominee's brother, Robert Miers. The president arranged a scholarship and job for the student at the university's campus computer center, Mr. Miers said. "Harriet and the family are grateful to this day."

And then he asks:
Hypothetically, if your daddy has a stroke when you're a freshman in college, and you stay close to home so you can work a scholarship job while you're going to the best college and then the best law school in town, and then you clerk for a local federal district judge, and you go to work for one of the best firms in town (but that town isn't Washington or New York), and you go on to rack up a string of exceptional professional successes — does that nevertheless mean you're forever after a "third-rate" lawyer, forever after unworthy to be considered qualified for the Supreme Court, because you didn't go off to some Ivy League school?

Just askin'.

Great question.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very valuable information and insight. I, too, am quite dismayed at the almost hysterical, irrational over reaction of some on the right. Seems like they're pulling a Pelosi...mouthing off to the cameras ...as if it's all about them abd their "feelings".

7:31 PM, October 07, 2005  

Post a Comment

<< Home