Beldar makes the case against Lithwick

I'd say he wins on summary judgment. Attorney Bill Dyer has a very good blog. Here he points out, politely but convincingly, that Dalia Lithwick of Slate is a liar. She responds, nicely, but fails to refute the charge.

Bottom line -- she slimed John Roberts with a patently false smear. She tried to cover herself by pleading humor, but Beldar slams the door with evidence and logic, leaving her exposed by the truth.